New York State Sportswriters Association   
    
→ Search
 
→ Rankings
NYSSWA rankings are updated weekly.
See the latest plus the earlier weeks'
updates on our rankings page.

 
 
NYSSWA All-State plaques
 
 
 
 
The Buffalo Sabres Chic
 
 

Friday, Nov. 20, 2026: Two Middletown coaches have resigned

    Leading off today: Chalk it up to any one of several reasons why -- the abrupt ending to the most successful season in six decades would be a good start -- but the Middletown football story is not fading away.

    We're now up to two coaching resignations, and that's before the district leadership gets around to conducting its investigation and reporting the findings related to the rule violation that resulted in a forfeit and disqualification from the Section 9 playoffs days before last weekend's Class AA final.

    According to News12.com, assistant coach Isaac Cayetano submitted his resignation on Wednesday, two days after head coach Tim Strenfel also made the decision to step down.

    Whereas Strenfel did not discuss his departure after nearly a decade on the job, Cayetano was forthcoming with thoughts about what went wrong in the player eligibility violation, which saw the then-unbeaten football team suit up a kicker who did not qualify to play in sectionals under the NYSPHSAA representation rule.

    Speaking to the news outlet, Cayetano acknowledged that the coaching staff bore some responsibility but also claimed Strenfel had consulted AD Justin Sturge before adding the kicker, who had been a full-time member of the boys soccer team this fall.

    The second-year assistant coach said the representation rule, about which ADs are reminded each fall by the NYSPHSAA during a mandatory meeting, was never properly communicated to Strenfel. He further stated that David Coates, who serves as a district consultant after retiring last spring as AD and is one of the two Section 9 representatives on the NYSPHSAA Executive Committee, could also have flagged the issue.

    "You can blame him. You can blame me. You can blame everyone on the staff," Cayetano said. "However, we have bosses as well, and we have people who are supposed to educate us."

    The story did not say whether News12 attempted to reach out to Sturge or Coates for comment on Cayetano's assertions.

    In his resignation letter to administrators and the school board, Cayetano lauded Strenfel.

    "He cares for our boys, whether they are white, Black, or brown," he wrote. "I have especially valued the respect and understanding he brings to the Black and brown young men who make up so much of this program. In my experience, that kind of care is far more valuable than knowing any rule or winning any game."

    He added: "If a situation involving a coach with Tim's character and commitment can end this way, with our boys paying the price for avoidable mistakes by adults, I want no part of continuing under those circumstances."

More Middletown

    (1) I awoke Thursday to a New York Post summary of the drama that engulfed the Middletown school district and community.

    Given that the paper has not covered high school sports in the five boroughs in at least a decade, I had low expectations for the reporting. Instead, I found no factual errors or mischaracterizations. In fact, the paper pointed out an important fact that had been showing up in few if any reports by other media outlets.

    People trying to rally support for Middletown last week repeatedly cited how the ineligible kicker only played 53 seconds in a blowout victory in the sectional semifinal. The wording easily could have led one to surmise that he was merely sent onto the field in the final minute of a blowout victory.

    The truth, documented in filings last week in State Supreme Court, is that he appeared in eight plays spread across the game. The kicker was brought in with the goal of pinning Valley Central deep in its own end following kickoffs. Rather than an afterthought, that qualified the kicker as an integral part of Middletown's special-teams strategy.

    Thus, kudos to the New York Post.

    Meanwhile, radio personalities, drive-by engagement farmers, and politicians jammed multiple factual errors -- here and here, for instance -- into their "reporting." Reader comments on stories posted online across the country are also loaded with faulty interpretations of the rules.

    (2) I meant to mention this last week, but the kot845.com website did an incredible job setting the table for Friday's courtroom proceedings, including linking to the New York State Unified Court System page containing all the exhibits, affidavits, and correspondence to the judge.

    One takeaway from it: There were a lot of billable hours involved.

Former Section 2 QB is top-rated college prospect

    Keegan Croucher, who began at Fonda-Fultonville in 2023 and now plays for Baylor School in Chattanooga, Tenn., is the No. 1 quarterback in the class of 2027 in the latest edition of the Rivals Top 300 recruiting rankings. Rivals lists Croucher, who played two seasons for Cheshire Academy in Connecticut before the move to Tennessee in January, as the No. 9 recruit overall among seniors.

    Croucher, who has committed to Ole Miss, has led his team to an 11-0 record and a top-10 national ranking this fall. The team plays in a state semifinal on Friday.

Krumenacker finishes at 322 victories

    Buddy Krumenacker's 45-year run as a Farmingdale's head football coach ended Sunday with an 18-14 loss to Oceanside in the semifinals of the Nassau Conference I playoffs.

    "In a place like Farmingdale you believe you can win all the time," he told Newsday. "There's obvious disappointment when you lose."

    Krumenacker, 79, finished with a record of 322-108-11, including 77-19-5 at Hempstead from 1978-88. He took over the top job at Farmingdale in 1993. His Farmingdale squads won nine Nassau Conference I titles, and two Long Island Class I championships.

Another record for Canisius' Kimble

    Canisius running back Elijah Kimble scored two touchdowns Saturday in a 41-23 win over St. Joe's to reach 102 for his career, setting the Western New York record.

    Clymer's Jehuu Caulcrick held the previous record of 101.

    Kimble broke the WNY rushing record earlier this season, and he Syracuse commit is over 7,000 for his career.

Longtime Section 4 administrator Ben Nelson dies

    Longtime Section 4 coach and administrator Ben Nelson, a NYSPHSAA and Basketball Coaches Association of New York Hall of Fame inductee, died this week.

    Nelson was a multi-sport coach at Oxford, leading boys and girls teams to multiple cross country, basketball and rack and field championships. He took over as the school's AD in 1988 and served as the Section 4 executive director from 1998-2021.

    Section 4's statement lauded Nelson for his focus on instilling character, responsibility, teamwork, perseverance, and leadership.

Did you notice?

    As was the case the previous four years, SUNY Cortland did not host the girls soccer final fours despite holding the contract. The college notified the NYSPHSAA last month that it was in the running to host first-round games in the NCAA Division III soccer tournament the same weekend as the high school semifinals and finals.

    As it turned out, Cortland's women received a bid but were sent to Hobart and William Smith Colleges in Geneva. The men were shipped to Montclair, N.J., where they won a pair of games to advance.

    With SUNY Cortland unavailable, the NYSPHSAA once again relied upon local high schools to host. As that's now become a habit, I would think any number of other sections also have clusters of suitable high school facilities that could submit bids. Unfortunately, the new Cortland contract runs through 2029.

Reversal in Rochester

    The Rochester City School District has reversed itself and will continue to offer competitive cheerleading as a sport.

    The initial decision to cut the program was announced last month and was met with immediate backlash.<>     Superintendent Eric J. Rosser announced the restoration but also announced that all the city high schools will be consolidated into a single competitive cheerleading team.

Illinois cross country champ under the microscope

    Kara Glenn blew away the field at the Illinois High School Association state meet two weekends ago, winning her race by 48 seconds. In fact, the St. Charles North junior shattered the nation high school record for a three-mile course by nearly 20 seconds.

    On the heels of a big sophomore track and field season and a string of cross country titles, the performance triggered nearly instant suspicion and online harassment.

    There was even a Change.org petition garnering 500 signatures that called for her to submit to testing to see if she might have gained an advantage possibly through the use of human growth hormone or a comparable hormone optimization therapy. The petition claimed she has undergone a significant physical transformation that includes a more defined jawline, visible facial hair, and a deeper voice.

    Glenn, who has already committed to the University of North Carolina, skipped the Nike Cross Nationals regional and has shut down the remainder of her season out of safety concerns. Both the runner and the school have restricted access to their Instagram accounts.

    "I'm all good," Glenn told Illinois Running News. "I just had enough of the harassment, and we decided I'm going to skip postseason and prepare for indoor."

Garbage in, garbage out

    Two high school football teams that thought they had qualified for the Georgia High School Association playoffs were punted from the brackets later in the day after a recalculation necessitated by some missing scores.

    The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported that Chamblee High (6-4) and Coosa High (3-7) were informed after the initial announcement of parings that they did not actually qualify.

          

HOME | BLOG | RANKINGS | BRACKETS | REFERENCE | KERR CUP | ABOUT US | ©2025 Abbott Trento Online Media, LLC. All rights reserved. | Contact us via e-mail.

→ Recent blogs and news
  • 11/20/26: Two Middletown football coaches resign
  • 11/14/26: Bennett defense, senior RB shine in win
  • 11/12/26: Delhi football tripped up by eligibility issue
  • 11/11/26: Middletown in court, East/WOIS reinstated
  • 11/9/26: Middletown punted from Section 9 final
  • 11/8/26: Sec. 5: East football season still alive

  • 10/30/26: Roch. CSD drops competitive cheer teams
  • 10/28/26: Lackawanna star breaks goals record
  • 10/24/26: Arrest made following sideline assault
  • 10/23/26: NYSPHSAA OK's 3 championship events
  • 10/19/26: Previewing the NYSPHSAA meeting
  • 10/19/26: Sec. 3 RB's 7 TDs beat undefeated foe
  • 10/16/26: Section 5 change weighs on state champ
  • 10/12/26: Canastota soccer star scores 12 goals
  • 10/11/26: Kimble sets WNY career rushing mark
  • 10/9/26: Essay: 'The press box is getting quieter'

  • 10/9/26: Golf champ Knapp won't defend her title
  • 10/5/26: 3 injuried in Fulton XC bus accident
  • 10/2/26: Yahoo report revisits helmet safety
  • 10/1/26: Glens Falls poised to land hoops tourney
  • 9/30/26: OK, what should Sec. 8 football do next?
  • 9/29/26: Massapequa snaps Garden City win streak
  • 9/28/26: Oceanside's forfeit is a head-scratcher
  • 9/26/26: No. 1 Iona Prep downs No. 2 Msgr. Farrell
  • 9/25/26: Storm, Massapequa-Garden City ahead
  • 9/21/26: A forfeit that didn't need to happen

  • 9/19/26: Is it football news or a police blotter?
  • 9/17/26: More football forfeits ahead of Week 3
  • 9/14/26: Reprieve for Port Jeff football players
  • 9/11/26: Tenn. private schools in unexpected clash
  • 9/5/26: Two more defending champs lose openers
  • 9/4/26: Iona Prep opens strong, beats Syr. CBA
  • 9/3/26: NYSSWA girls lacrosse all-state team
  • 9/2/26: Onondaga grid season on hold after crash
  • 8/27/26: Sec. 2 soccer star to skip H.S. season
  • 8/20/26: NYSSWA boys lacrosse all-state team

  • 8/18/26: L.I. school training students to referee
  • 8/17/26: Rye wins Kerr Cup All-Sport Championship
  • 8/15/26: 5 Section 2 teams drop to 8-man football
  • 8/12/26: NYSSWA All-State Baseball selections
  • 8/7/26: Jamesville-DeWitt switches leagues again
  • 8/1/26: Cambridge/Salem won't field football team
  • 7/30/26: F-M isn't bringing back XC coach Bill Aris
  • 7/27/26: Section 1's private schools win appeal
  • 7/26/26: Previewing this week's NYSPHSAA meeting
  • 7/24/26: NYSSWA Flag Football All-State Team

  • 7/21/26: Brentwood boys soccer coach Ron Eden dies
  • 7/16/26: Livonia coach terminated at lunch table
  • 7/14/26: Section 5 lacrosse legend Ernie Lisi dies
  • 7/10/26: New NFHS bats rule raises concerns
  • 7/2/26: New York Junior Golf Championships
  • 6/30/26: N.Y. unaffected by Supreme Court ruling
  • 6/27/26: N.J.'s scandalous 'reclassification mills'
  • 6/25/26: All-state softball selections announced
  • 6/25/26: An NCAA change helpful to H.S. prospects
  • 6/16/26: Transgender athlete wins state track title

  • 6/12/26: St. Joe's investigating its baseball 'culture'
  • 6/9/26: Florida adding super playoff division
  • 5/28/26: Coach Bill Aris on leave during F-M probe
  • 5/28/26: Eligibility issue costs Ross spot in final
  • 5/24/26: New York flag football playoff scoreboard
  • 5/24/26: Penalties reduced for Stepinac basketball
  • 5/18/26: Girls basketball all-state team (small schools)
  • 5/11/26: Girls basketball all-state team (large schools)
  • 5/9/26: 2 adults arrested after L.I. flag football game
  • 5/7/26: NYSPHSAA committee quashes Sec. 1 push

    MORE BLOGS FROM THE CURRENT SCHOOL YEAR

  •    NYSSWA Road to Syracuse football website    NYRA Awards and Trophies