Key: (A)-AIS, (C)-CHSAA, (P)-PSAL. All others are NYSPHSAA schools.
| | Class AA | Class A | Class B | |
| 2019 | L.I. Lutheran (A) | Albany Academy (A) | Glens Falls | |
| 2018 | Arch. Stepinac (C) | Park School (C) | Fannie Lou Hamer (P) | |
| 2017 | Abraham Lincoln (P) | Albany Academy (A) | Manhattan LaSalle (C) | |
| 2016 | Thomas Jefferson (P) | Albany Academy (A) | Collegiate (A) | |
| 2015 | Wings Academy (P) | Canisius (C) | Park School (C) | |
| 2014 | Christ The King (C) | Scotia-Glenville | Westhill | |
| 2013 | Christ The King (C) | Albany Academy (A) | Msgr. Scanlan (C) | |
| 2012 | Boys & Girls (P) | L.I. Lutheran (A) | Collegiate (A) | |
| 2011 | Mount Vernon | L.I. Lutheran (A) | Collegiate (A) | |
| 2010 | Christ The King (C) | Nichols (C) | Collegiate (A) | |
| 2009 | Rice (C) | L.I. Lutheran (A) | Collegiate (A) | |
| 2008 | Abraham Lincoln (P) | Jamesville-DeWitt | Collegiate (A) | |
| 2007 | Abraham Lincoln (P) | Peekskill | Malverne | |
| 2006 | Mount Vernon | Peekskill | Global Studies (P) | |
| 2005 | Niagara Falls | St. Anthony's (C) | Regis (C) | |
| 2004 | Mount Vernon | Jamesville-Dewitt | John F. Kennedy | |
| | | | | |
| | Class A | Class B | Class C | |
| 2003 | Abraham Lincoln (P) | Amityville | Brooklyn Friends (A) | |
| 2002 | Rice (C) | Manhasset St. Mary (C) | Lawrence Woodmere (A) | |
| 2001 | St. Raymond's (C) | Amityville | Buffalo Traditional | |
| 2000 | Mount Vernon | Manhasset St. Mary (C) | Brooklyn Poly Prep (A) | |
| 1999 | Rice (C) | Buff. Turner-Carroll (C) | Lawrence Woodmere (A) | |
| 1998 | Rice (C) | Westhampton | Buff. Turner-Carroll (C) | |
| 1997 | Long Is. Lutheran (A) | St. Dominic (C) | New Ro. Salesian (C) | |
| 1996 | Rice (C) | Peekskill | Buffalo Traditional | |
| 1995 | Abraham Lincoln (P) | Mount St. Michael (C) | Buffalo Nichols (A) | |
| 1994 | Rice (C) | Long Is. Lutheran (A) | Cardinal O'Hara (C) | |
| 1993 | St. Raymond's (C) | Norwich | Regis (C) | |
| 1992 | Bishop Loughlin (C) | Syracuse Fowler | Seneca Falls Mynderse | |
| 1991 | Mount Vernon | Syracuse Nottingham | Watervliet | |
| 1990 | Grady (P) | Jamesville-DeWitt | Buffalo Nichols (A) | |
| 1989 | Christ The King (C) | Nazareth (C) | Lyons | |
| 1988 | Tolentine (C) | Niagara Falls LaSalle | Buff. Turner-Carroll (C) | |
| 1987 | Our Sav. Lutheran (A) | Syracuse Nottingham | Niagara Trott Vocational | |
| | | | | |
| | Class A | Class B | Class C | Class D |
| 1986 | Binghamton | Xaverian (C) | Buffalo Nichols (A) | Bridgehampton |
| 1985 | All Hallows (C) | Samuel Gompers (P) | Buffalo Nichols (A) | Oswego Cunningham |
| 1984 | Harry S Truman (P) | Buffalo Bennett | Rochester Charlotte | Bridgehampton |
| 1983 | North Babylon | Bishop Loughlin (C) | Rochester Charlotte | Our Sav. Lutheran (A) |
| 1982 | Franklin (P) | Syracuse Nottingham | Long Is. Lutheran (A) | New York Mills |
| 1981 | Xaverian (C) | Malverne | Long Is. Lutheran (A) | Our Sav. Lutheran (A) |
| 1980 | Holy Trinity (C) | Tolentine (C) | St. Dominic (C) | Bridgehampton |
| | | | | |
| | Class AAA | Class AA | Class A | Class B |
| 1979 | St. Anthony's (C) | Nazareth (C) | St. Agnes (C) | St. John Neumann (C) |
