Leading off today: What's the difference between the Green Tech football team headed into its first varsity season and the Super Bowl XLV champion Green Bay Packers?
Not much in the eyes of Section 2.
In a move flying in the face of all logic and most precedent, Green Tech will almost certainly play in Class AA when it makes its varsity debut in September, The Times Union reported this week.
Green Tech, an all-boys charter school with 263 students who land classroom seats by lottery, has been placed in the Liberty Division alongside the likes of Schenectady (2,140 students), Shaker (1,563) and Colonie (1,390) based upon decisions by the Section 2 football committee in December and the Section 2 classification committee on Thursday.
The organization's Athletic Council still needs to sign off on the decision, but sectional football coordinator Gary VanDerzee doesn't believe that will be an issue. "Generally, the Athletic Council supports the recommendations from the other committees," VanDerzee told the newspaper.
If that happens in this instance, it calls into question the judgment of the governing body of Albany-area schools within the New York State Public High School Athletic Association. Evidence suggests the placement of a first-year team into the highest class might be more a matter of convenience than one rooted in logic.
With 2010 state finalist Troy dropping down to Class A based upon enrollment this fall, moving Green Tech into Class AA allows the section to set up two seven-team divisions in the largest class. Meanwhile, Class B tentatively has 11 teams, meaning one school each week will have to look outside its class or outside Section 2 for a game; the football committee has already drafted an distributed its proposed 2011 schedule.
But VanDerzee said the football committee's rationale revolved around two key factors.
"Being a charter school, the state treats them like a private school," VanDerzee said. "The school has no tuition fees and is drawing kids from the Albany School District."
Assuming that's true, it seems a contradiction then to have four existing private-school programs play at less one class below the highest level: Bishop Maginn in Class A, Albany Academy (which played in a NYSPHSAA final as recently as 2006 and has an enrollment virtually identical to Green Tech) in B, and Bishop Gibbons and Saratoga Central Catholic in D.
And it's not as though Green Tech is blessed with either the resources or the track record to leave the likes of Schenectady or Colonie shaking in their cleats. Though the Eagles JVs were 7-1 for coach Pete Porcelli last fall, two of the victories were by forfeit. In addition:
•The JV schedule consisted of Class A Averill Park and a blend of opponents from classes B, C and D. Green Tech lost to Class B Cobleskill and allowed 28 points or more in four of its six games, the paper reported. Further, the Green Tech roster included several juniors, somewhat rare among JV programs, because there was no varsity team yet.
•The school has neither an adequate practice field nor a weight room. Administrators are seeking to hold home games at Bleecker Stadium.