New York State Sportswriters Association   
    

Search
 
→ Rankings
NYSSWA rankings are updated weekly.
See the latest plus the earlier weeks'
updates on our rankings page.

 

 
John Moriello's NYSSWA blog
Wednesday, Aug. 5, 2009: The club vs. school issue is alive and well
   Leading off today: Conflicting loyalties.

   It's an issue that many of us who've covered high school sports over the years have seen first-hand: Club and Olympic Development Program soccer coaches discouraging players from participating in other school sports during the winter and spring . . . AAU basketball coaches shuttling basketball prospects all around the country during the summer and "assisting" in their transfers from CHSAA to PSAL schools (or vice versa) . . . And the beat goes on.

   Name a sport and there's almost some ongoing conflict.

   Yesterday, the New York Daily News did a lengthy piece on the conflict between club and school programs in the sport of track and field, and examples cited by reporter Ebenezer Samuel should raise alarm signals.

   Sports must above all else be a safe haven for athletes, which is to say that the first responsibility of any school or club coach is to assure the well-being of the students. And achievement/success for the athlete is more important than what those accomplishments do to further a coach's ambition.

   And if there's a school vs. club conflict not covered above, then the coach needs to remember who's paying the freight. If you're drawing a check from the school (a.k.a. the taxpayers), then your allegiance needs to be to the school when all else is equal.

   And in cases in which the school and club coaches are not the same person, the rule should be clear. The club coach should have no say while the high school season is in progress.

   That does not appear to have been the case with Springfield Gardens sprinter Rashawn Simpson. In June, he ended up running for his club and school teams on consecutive days. Competeing in the Junior Olympics qualifier almost certainly led to a sixth-place finish in the PSAL outdoor championships, costing him a lane in the state meet at Cicero-North Syracuse the following week.

   "If I had to do it over again, I wouldn't have run JO," Simpson told the paper.

   "The high school should feed the club team in the summer, and vice versa," said 1996 Olympic gold medalist Derrick Adkins, director of track and field at the Armory in Manhattan. "It should all work together for the good of the student-athlete."

   The newspaper story cited several other conflicts, chiefly involving PSAL teams and coaches. It's less of an issue at CHSAA schools, which typically do not face the same sort of union restrictions when it comes to hiring. The worst was probably Transit Tech runners Julian Wood and Malik Sykes telling coach Sydney McIntosh they would only compete if they could skip team practices and train with their club team. McIntosh said no.

   Transit Tech athlete Dexter Bollers approved of McIntosh's stance.

   "Julian, he was always like, 'I'm trying to help you guys

  

NYSSWA All-Sport Championship
MAIN | 2008-09 top overall school scores
Class-by-class boys | Class-by-class girls
More about the NYSSWA All-Sport Championship

out,'" he said. "They'll walk around like they're trying to help you out."

   St. Ray's junior picks Arizona: Sean Miller doesn't have any commitments yet from players in the Class of 2010, but the new men's basketball coach at Arizona has landed his first junior.

   St. Raymond’s standout Sidiki Johnson has verbally committed to Arizona, FiveBoroSports.com reported over the weekend. The 6-foot-7 forward, who averaged 11.3 points as a sophomore, was attracting interest from Kentucky, Virginia Tech and most of the Big East.

   Miller, a former Pitt star who most recently coached at Xavier, made solid inroads into New York City in the spring when he landed incoming freshmen Lamont (Momo) Jones and Kevin Parrom.

   Hey, your 15 minutes are up: Former Buffalo McKinley basketball player Jayvonna Kincannon is back in the news for the wrong reasons. She faces allegations that she punched a police officer, WIVB-TV reported.

   Prosecutors allege she punched Buffalo Police Officer Kim Beaty as Kincannon's grandmother Marsha Jones was being taken into custody last Wednesday. Kincannon, her grandmother, and aunt, Darlene Fitzgerald, were all arrested during a disturbance on Buffalo's east side.

   Kincannon was in the news last year for being suspended from school for five weeks while trying to speak out on behalf of a fired volunteer basketball coach.

   Extra points: NYSSWA member Steve Grandin has pulled together the class-by-class enrollment data for the NYSPHSAA's football-playing schools. That PDF file is always a handy reference tool. Let us know if you find any possible errors and I'll pass the info along to Steve. . . . Offensive lineman Sean Donnelly of Trinity-Pawling says he will play football at Tulane beginning in September 2010. The 6-foot-8, 290-pound left tackle was being recruited mostly by Division I-AA programs.


Read previous blog entries from John Moriello. | Send us an e-mail. | Subscribe to RSS feed.


→ Recent blogs and news     NYSSWA RSS feed
  • 1/18/25: Colonie bowler's 890 series sets U.S. mark
  • 1/16/25: Somers football likely to remain in Class A
  • 1/15/25: All-state football: Classes AA and A
  • 1/14/25: Harper steps down at Clymer/Sherman/Panama
  • 1/10/25: Four L.I. districts still battling mascot rule
  • 1/8/25: All-state football: Classes B, C, D and 8-man
  • 12/20/24: Canastota's Laidlaw chalks up 900th win
  • 12/17/24: William Floyd assistant dies in car crash
  • 12/11/24: AD at Sec. 2 powerhouse will step down

  • 12/9/24: Girls soccer all-state selections announced
  • 12/8/24: Recapping the weekend NYSPHSAA football finals
  • 12/7/24: Which mascots replaced Indians, Warriors?
  • 12/6/24: Publics vs. privates issue resurfaces
  • 12/5/24: NYSPHSAA makes rare mid-year class change
  • 12/2/24: Short-handed Conn. team forfeits playoff game
  • 12/1/24: Massapequa hockey player dies during game
  • 11/27/24: Column: Crisis in Sec. 5 small-school football
  • 11/24/24: PSAL cracks down, imposes hoops forfeits
  • 11/22/24: Bayport-Blue Point football extends streaks

  • 11/19/24: Some thoughts following the playoffs weekend
  • 11/15/24: Plainedge football pulls off last-play win
  • 11/8/24: Court restores Syracuse ITC to grid playoffs
  • 11/6/24: West Islip girls soccer advances on PKs
  • 11/5/24: Newburgh forfeits sectional football opener
  • 11/2/24: Top-ranked 'D' football team's season over
  • 10/31/24: Herricks' Walia wins state tennis singles title
  • 10/28/24: S-WR senior making the grade in 2 sports
  • 10/27/24: Copiague football ends its record losing streak
  • 10/26/24: Herkimer gridders claw way back to .500

  • 10/25/24: Girls lacrosse schedule proposal nixed
  • 10/22/24: NYSPHSAA Exec Committee meeting preview
  • 10/19/24: Albany CBA wins Sec. 2 football showdown
  • 10/18/24: Baldwinsville cracks 'USAT' eSports rankings
  • 10/16/24: Wisc. hits schools hard for paperwork glitch
  • 10/14/24: Bethlehem girls, Macchia win Eastern States
  • 10/13/24: Iona Prep slips past Hayes in 'AA" showdown
  • 10/11/24: La. QB throws for 817 yards in overtime loss
  • 10/10/24: Report: N.Y. girls to join transgender protest
  • 10/7/24: More eight-man teams left stranded in Week 5

  • 10/5/24: 18 ranked N.Y. football teams fall in Friday action
  • 10/4/24: Longest U.S. football futility streak continues
  • 10/3/24: Syracuse.com's twist on fantasy football
  • 9/30/24: M-E edges Waverly in battle of No. 1 teams
  • 9/27/24: Report: Sec. 3 athletes flock to NIL Club
  • 9/25/24: Ex-Kellenberg QB sets off an NIL drama
  • 9/23/24: NYSPHSAA warns about potential NIL isssue
  • 9/21/24: South Park's Nunes shatters N.Y. rushing record
  • 9/20/24: Storytelling in H.S. sports is alive and well
  • 9/19/24: Longtime SWR coach Paul Koretzki, 84, dies

  • 9/17/24: Western N.Y. teams embracing Guardian Caps
  • 9/15/24: N.J. shows us N.Y. football has a ways to go
  • 9/14/24: Another UPrep game, another fan incident
  • 9/13/24: Ohio wrestles with aftermath of shootings
  • 9/11/24: Mass. school forfeits over male opponent
  • 9/10/24: Regents table vote on expanding mixed competition
  • 9/9/24: Shot clock experiment will change lacrosse
  • 9/7/24: Garden City sets L.I. football record
  • 9/6/24: Lawsuit takes aim at N.C.'s NIL ban
  • 9/5/24: New York's Week 0 football intrigue

  •   
    This Site
    HOME
    BLOG
    RANKINGS
    BRACKETS
    REFERENCE
    KERR CUP
    ABOUT US

    ©2024 Abbott Trento Online Media.
    All rights reserved.
    Contact us via e-mail.

       NYSSWA football site