New York State Sportswriters Association   
    
Search

 

NYSSWA All-State plaques

John Moriello's NYSSWA blog
Monday, Sept. 7, 2009: PSAL critics ready to say 'I told you so'
   Leading off today: "I told you so."

   Be prepared to hear that phrase this autumn around the New York City soccer scene as the PSAL tries to execute its move of the girls season from the spring to the fall by shifting some games to weekends beginning this month.

   It may be the right thing to do from a fairness (and legal) point of view, but it still has "epic fail" written all over it, which is what vocal critics have contended since the moment the PSAL headed off a Title IX complaint by making the change.

   "There is going to be low attendance at games because of babysitting, jobs, family obligations, church,” No. 1 critic Bob Sprance, the Forest Hills girls coach, told The New York Post.

   Sprance says at least one of his players is unavailable on Sundays because of religious obligations, and there are also conflicts with SAT preparation and extracurricular activities on Saturday.

   There will also be weekend travel involved to sometimes-distant neutral fields for games beginning as early as 9 a.m. to accommodate double- and tripleheaders. That has "multiple forfeits" written all over it.

   The first fallout from the season change came when a number of coaches who previously held both positions had to choose between running their schools' boys or girls programs. The proverbial other shoe will drop if weather or other factors cause too many games to be rescheduled; assuming fields are found, there might not be enough officials available because refs are already spread thin across the PSAL, CHSAA and colleges.

   Referee assigner Alan Wharton told the paper he has all

  
RoadToSyracuse.com
RoadToSyracuse.com Football Site

the games covered but, "Once the rains come, all bets are off."

   More soccer: Highly regarded Chaminade and St. Anthony's picked up their first boys soccer victories of the season yesterday. Brandon Pues scored the winner for Chaminade in a 2-1 victory vs. New Jersey's Don Bosco Prep, and the Friars got single goals from three players in a 3-1 wit over Hillsdale (N.J.) Pascack Valley.

   Extra points: The Journal News reports that Ossining's Dakota Degree broke an ankle recently in a football scrimmage and will miss his senior season. The 6-foot-4, 315-pound lineman is still regarded as a possible Division I propect. . . . The Democrat and Chronicle reported that Jerrold Brooks of Rochester East and Ronnie Molina of Marshall lost their appeals for an extra year of football eligibility.


Read previous blog entries from John Moriello. | Send us an e-mail. | Subscribe to RSS feed.


HOME | BLOG | RANKINGS | BRACKETS | REFERENCE | KERR CUP | ABOUT US | ©2025 Abbott Trento Online Media, LLC. All rights reserved. | Contact us via e-mail.

→ Recent blogs and news
  • 4/6/26: You're not imagining it's been a wet spring
  • 4/2/26: Plainedge reversal puts 8th-grader on field
  • 4/1/26: Where the private vs. public issue stands
  • 3/31/26: Dior Johnson is on the move ... again
  • 3/20/26: Class changes and Albion-Medina merger
  • 3/18/26: Section 3 foes drop CBA from schedule
  • 3/8/26: Warwick vaulter, McQuaid swimmers win big
  • 3/5/26: Will. East baseball coach reappointed
  • 3/1/26: Wrapup of weekend N.Y. championship action
  • 2/18/26: Mass. coaches out over recorded comments

  • 2/14/26: Warsaw ends season as probe continues
  • 2/12/26: Section 4 reporter Kevin Stevens, 62, dies
  • 2/5/26: Public vs. private issue under study again
  • 2/2/26: NYSPHSAA meeting will revive hot topic
  • 1/31/26: Iona Prep, Syr. CBA to meet in grid opener
  • 1/26/26: College recruiting landscape has changed
  • 1/22/26: Blackford steps down at Westmoreland
  • 1/18/26: Sec. 2 coach accused of hitting athlete
  • 1/17/26: Ref stricken at Nassau Co. basketball game
  • 1/14/26: NYSSWA all-state football team, Part 2

  • 1/13/26: Fan arrested after Suffolk Co. basketball fight
  • 1/12/26: Alabama takes on public vs. private issue
  • 1/11/26: S-WR wrestler wins 4th Eastern States title
  • 1/8/26: Poughkeepsie gets OK to return to Sec. 9
  • 1/7/26: NYSSWA all-state football team, Part 1
  • 1/5/26: GoFundMe created to aid Schroeder coach
  • 1/2/26: Pleasantville coach goes for victory No. 500
  • 12/27/25: USATF bans ex-Saratoga Springs coaches
  • 12/12/25: Sec. 2 and hockey officials remain far apart
  • 12/10/25: Girls soccer all-state selections announced

  • 12/4/25: Boys soccer all-state selections announced
  • 11/30/25: BBP wins title on 47-yard FG as time expires
  • 11/26/25: Section 2 in dispute with hockey officials
  • 11/26/25: Garden City win streak is nation's longest
  • 11/23/25: What watching 34 football games revealed
  • 11/17/25: Burnt Hills on track for huge month
  • 11/13/25: Two titles in 24 hours for Section 5 pair
  • 11/9/25: BH-BL girls VB wins 23rd straight Sec. 2 title
  • 11/6/25: Tracking how at-large teams have fared
  • 11/5/25: OT goal is 100th of year for Mount's Huleatt

  • 11/2/25: Garden City's 62nd straight win ties record
  • 10/31/25: New twist to when a tie in final isn't a tie
  • 10/30/25: Shen freshman wins NYSPHSAA tennis title
  • 10/28/25: Sec. 6 blowouts should raise eyebrows
  • 10/24/25: Ohio makes ill-advised football decision
  • 10/22/25: NYSPHSAA Exec. Committee meeting recap
  • 10/20/25: Section 6 RB scores nine TDs in 76-3 win
  • 10/18/25: Iona Prep tumbles on upset-filled night
  • 10/17/25: L.I. soccer team may mean tough choices
  • 10/16/25: Mount Academy senior sets 2 goal marks

    MORE BLOGS FROM THE CURRENT SCHOOL YEAR

  •    NYSSWA Road to Syracuse football website    NYRA Awards and Trophies